Some of you may have recently noticed
the discussion around a disturbing ad campaign implemented by a pornographic
website named PornHub. Their campaign gained not only my attention, but the negative attention of many other American citizens. PornHub held a contest
asking that applicants to submit non-pornographic advertisement ideas to
promote the site. The winner of Pornhub’s ad campaign contest is a depiction of
a hand forming the shape of a heart with an accompanying slogan “ALL YOU NEED
IS HAND”.
PornHub subsequently filmed a video underneath the billboard in which
a hired choir sings a rendition of the song “All You Need Is Love,” but replaces
the word “love” with “hand”. The overall message of this ad was direct; you
don’t need love, you only need a hand which will allow you to satisfy your
sexual desires independently from a relationship.
This campaign is unsettling to me because
I believe that it contributes to the misperception of sexual normative. As confirmed
by studies, the media’s inflated portrayals of sexual encounters cause individuals
to believe that their peers are significantly more sexually permissive and
active than is actually the case (Chia & Gunther, 2006). This study confirms
that mediated sexual messages create an illusion that sexual encounters are
pervasive among peers, which consequently makes young individuals more likely
to say they that they will engage in casual sexual activity and engage this
activity at an earlier stage in dating (Chia & Gunther, 2006).
Perceived sexual peer norms have been
shown to significantly affect adolescents’ sexual behavior. The disproportionate
representations of sex within the media are therefore problematic in that they
produce standards regarding sexuality that are used as an indicator of normality.
Pornhub’s ad campaign encourages pornography usage by creating the
misconception that porn is normal and that everyone is engaging in this
activity. Advertisements, such as the one created by PornHub, construct the
notion that sexual actions are commonplace. This perceived normalcy may cause individuals
to engage in sexual activities that are dangerous or unsuitable for their
developmental stage, therefore increasing their risk for sexually transmitted diseases,
pregnancy, and dysfunctional relationships.
To counteract the negative effects of PornHub’s
“ALL YOU NEED IS HAND” campaign, an organization entitled “Fight the New Drug” wrote
a blog post that depicts some of the PornHub’s troubling contest submissions
and revised them in order to portray a more realistic perspective on porn
usage. This blog post reached over a million people on Facebook, and recent updates
state that the Pornhub billboard had been taken down.
It is important that society receives balanced
and proportionate representations of sexuality within the media in order to
maintain a healthy society. Sex does happen, but the frequency and sexual behaviors
portrayed in the media do not reflect the real world. It is time that the media
stops infiltrating society with inaccurate representations of the sex, but
since it is unlikely that this will cease, we as a society should speak out against
these troubling representations because, as seen in the instance of PornHub’s campaign,
people can change the messages that attempt to change us.
References
Chia, S. C., & Gunther, A. C.
(2006). How media contribute to misperceptions of social norms about sex. Mass
Communication & Society, 9(3), 301-320.
Megan, I think your application of the Chia article to pornography usage and perceived sexual norms among peers is really interesting.The fact that it is becoming so normalized and advertised in our culture definitely has negative consequences, not only in getting people to use porn more frequently but also that it negatively impacts relationships as well.
ReplyDeleteYour post inspired me to find research that illustrates how pornography usage negatively affects societies and relationships and what I found is kind of alarming. Destin Stewart and Dawn Szymanski wrote about their pornography research in their 2012 article, "Young Adult Women's Reports of Their Male Romantic Partner's Pornography Use as a Correlate of Their Self-Esteem, Relationship Quality, and Sexual Satisfaction." What they found is that women often have decreased self-esteem and sexual satisfaction after discovering that their male counterparts are engaging in frequent porn use. They also found that this porn use had a negative impact on their relationship satisfaction and over relationship quality.
I think without this knowledge it is easy to not understand why it is problematic for pornography to be advertised, because who cares if people are using pornography for sexual pleasure? But when it really starts to set in that viewing pornography negatively affects relationships, self-esteem, and objectifies peoples' bodies, it becomes deeply apparent just how pornography can be.
Overall, great post!
References:
Stewart, D., & Szymanski, D. (2012). Young Adult Women's Reports of Their Male Romantic Partner's Pornography Use as a Correlate of Their Self-Esteem, Relationship Quality, and Sexual Satisfaction. Sex Roles, 67(5/6), 257-271. doi:10.1007/s11199-012-0164-0