As I was perusing Buzzfeed this weekend, I stumbled across a
quiz that I found to be extremely interesting and relevant to Brown et. al.’s
article “Sex, Sexuality, Sexting, and Sex Ed.” The quiz is titled “How Normal Are Your Sex Habits?” and it asks a number of questions ranging from “How old
were you when your parents gave you “the talk”?” to “How often do you masturbate?”
(The full list can be seen below). After each question and once the user responds a “poll” is revealed that shows him/her where he/she stands in relation to
others who have taken the quiz (a sample is seen below).
List of Questions
- How old were you when your parents gave you “the talk”
- What age did you loose your virginity?
- How many sexual partners have you had?
- Do you watch porn?
- How often do you masturbate?
- How long do you typically spend on foreplay
- How often do you climax during sex?
- How often do you have sex?
- Which one of these is your favorite position?
- Does size matter?
- Have you exchanged racy photos?
- When performing oral sex do you spit or swallow?
- Do you use protection?
- Have you ever tried anal sex?
- How long do you wait to have sex with someone?
- How would you rate yourself in bed?
Example of poll
This quiz offers potential for both positive and negative effects for young people trying to navigate their sex life much like most new media outlets, new media being defined as “digital media, include text messaging on cell
phones, MP3 players (e.g., iPods), blogs or chat rooms on Web sites, and
Internet social networking sites (SNS) such as Facebook or MySpace, where many
users can simultaneously create and communicate on the same Web pages” (Brown
et. al., p. 12, 2009).
The positives
Brown et. al.’s article states that, “Most teens (and
youth advocates) agree that the Internet is a valuable place to turn for
answers to embarrassing sex-related questions, to learn more about
uncomfortable topics, to familiarize themselves with intimate body parts, and
to gain perspective on conditions and sexual practices” (Brown et. al., p. 12,
2009). This quiz covers topics such as
penis size, masturbation, skill level in bed, and favorite sex position, many
of which are uncomfortable topics that can be hard to gain information about in
the real world or through traditional media that is generally more censored. After taking the poll myself, and looking at
the polling numbers on particular questions, I found the answers to a few of
the questions to have the potential to positively affect the user. One such question deals with protection. The answer poll suggests that 47% of
people always use protection. While this number isn’t
as high as most educators would like it too be, it does send the message that
many people use protection all the time. Therefore the user might be more
inclined to use protection in their own sexual endeavors after being exposed to this information. The question “How
often do you typically spend on foreplay” also has the potential to aid a user
in navigating his/her sex life and sexual pleasure. Those who are well versed in
sexual knowledge know that foreplay plays a major role in sexual pleasure. This
question serves as a platform for discovery as a user who may not be familiar with
the term might be more likely to look into it further and potentially use his/her newfound knowledge to enhance his/her own sexual pleasure. Lastly, the quiz also serves as a center for sexual
self-expression. By responding to these questions, even though it is
anonymously, users are sharing their experiences and contributing to the
masses. Brown et. al.’s piece states that “In fact, it has been repeatedly
argued that sexual self-expression on the Internet can be functional for
adolescents. The Internet provides a relatively safe space for teens to explore
and define themselves as sexual beings” supporting the notion that a quiz such
as this has the potential to positively influence its users due to its ability
to act as a safe space for sexual expression (Brown et. al., p. 14, 2009).
The negatives
While a quiz like this has the potential to positively
influence its users it seems to have an even greater potential to negatively
influence them in a number of ways. First of all, the shear title of the quiz
has the ability to make a user whose responses do not line up to the majority
feel as though their sexual life is “abnormal,” even if it isn’t. Questions
like “Does size matter?” “While performing oral do you spit or swallow?” or “How many
partners have you had?” also have the potential to make people feel inadequate
and insecure about their sexual ability and experience. Furthermore, this quiz
is not necessarily a representative sample and therefore the “norm” cannot be accurately quantified by the responses given, even though the quiz presents itself as though this
is the case. This is particularly concerning when looking at some of the
responses that I saw when taking the quiz myself. One such example can be seen in the response
to the question “Do you watch porn?”The poll shows over half having watched porn. This “finding” potentially has users believing that
most people watch porn, proliferating and encouraging the viewing of porn especially
by adolescents who are presumably a large portion of the Buzzfeed audience.
This is an issue because the viewing of porn by adolescents has proven to be
harmful to society as, “Longitudinal studies have found that such exposure
predicts less progressive gender role attitudes and perpetration of sexual
harassment for males, and sexual uncertainty, uncommitted sexual exploration
(i.e., one-night stands, hooking up), earlier oral sex and sexual intercourse
for both males and females” (Brown & L’Engle, 2009; Peter & Valkenburg,
2006, 2008a, b). Another example can be seen in the response to the finding, “Have
you exchanged racy photos” where a majority of the users said that they had.
The first problem with this question is the definition of “racy.” As its not explicitly
defined the ability for interpretation of its definition is vast. Therefore people
might believe that the majority of people are sending “racy” photos even if
they are not, because of sampling error. Perpetuating “sexting” as this quiz does is
another potential issue for society as studies have shown that it increases
self-objectification in women and can lead consequences as Brown et. al. states, “Reputations are
harmed, relationships broken, and friendships shattered when receivers of naked
images violate senders’ trust by sending the images on to others” (Brown et.
al., p. 15, 2009). Therefore, this quiz is potentially encouraging behavior under the veil of normalcy that
creating a potential for major societal implications.
Overall, while this Buzzfeed quiz does have the potential
to positively affect its viewers through providing them with sexual education,
encourage them to seek out more information about sexual topics they have
little knowledge about, and allow for sexual self expression, it does so under
the false pretenses that the responses given reveal what is “normal,” leading
to a great deal of potential negative outcomes for users and society at large.
References
References
Brown, J. D., Keller, S., & Stern, S. (2009). Sex, sexuality, sexting, and sexed:Adolescents and the media. Prevention
Researcher, 16(4), 12-°©‐16.
Hey Sam,
ReplyDeleteI actually saw this same quiz on Buzzfeed and I found it somewhat disturbing. I agree with you that the title alone, makes it seem like you may have an abnormal sex life if you don't fall into the same category as the other people taking this quiz. After all, we are comm students and know that this isn't necessarily a real measure of sexual behaviors to people, but for those who are not aware of this, they could have negative effects to taking this quiz.
I don't even really think there are that many positives to this quiz. Yes, I do agree in thinking that the internet is sometimes a safe space to explore sexual knowledge, but this is definitely not one of those spaces. I think the negative effects of this and the over-compensation for what those are partaking in around you, out-weigh any potential positives.
Great post!
Hi Sam,
ReplyDeleteInteresting post! I wanted to echo what Maura brought up and say that as Comm majors it comes with ease to us to call B.S. on quizzes like this. Their operationalization is most likely hopelessly flawed and I'm sure there was no legitimate methodology behind it. However, I would like to challenge one thing that you did mention in your post about sexting and its implications on people who take this quiz. Although I 100% agree that it has negative effects on body image, I would say the part about friendships and relationships might not be the case for quiz takers. I might be wrong, but I think Buzzfeed is most popular among young adults (I might just think this because I'm in college and I know the college kid demographic is one that is heavily targeted by it). And, considering that the whole "Reputations are harmed, relationships broken, and friendships shattered when receivers of naked images violate senders’ trust by sending the images on to others” (Brown et al, 2009) is arguably more of an issue among teenagers, its inclusion in the quiz might not be as much of a problem as it might originally seem. I think people who have entered adulthood handle sexting in a much more mature way than teens do. But I could be wrong. Thoughts?